Quick Answer
Private pay therapists earn $159 per session on average versus $111 on insurance panels, a 43% gap. At 20 sessions per week that is roughly $50,000 more per year in gross revenue. But insurance makes caseload-building easier early in your career, and the hidden costs of each model change the math. The right answer depends on your career stage, location, specialty, and risk tolerance.
1The real income difference
Heard's 2025 Financial State of Private Practice report gives the clearest numbers on the income gap between models. Here is what the data shows:
At 20 sessions per week, 48 working weeks per year, that gap totals $46,080 in additional gross revenue for private pay. Before accounting for the administrative overhead that insurance adds.
But gross revenue is not the whole story. Insurance billing adds costs. And building a private pay caseload takes longer and requires different investments. The net income comparison looks like this for a fully-loaded solo practice:
| Factor | Insurance | Private Pay |
|---|---|---|
| Average rate / session | $111 | $159 |
| 20 sessions/week gross (48 wks) | $106,560 | $152,640 |
| Billing admin cost / month | $50–$150 | $0 |
| Prior auth time cost (at $75/hr) | ~$600–$1,200/mo | $0 |
| Marketing cost to fill caseload | Lower (directories) | Higher (SEO/referrals) |
| Time to full caseload | Faster (12–18 mo) | Slower (18–30 mo) |
| Estimated net advantage | — | +$30,000–$45,000/yr |
The net advantage for private pay is real but not as large as the per-session gap suggests. The tradeoff is mostly in the early years, when building a private pay caseload takes more time and investment.
2The honest case for accepting insurance
Insurance gets dismissed too quickly in therapist communities. There are genuine reasons to stay on panels, and dismissing them makes this a worse decision for some therapists.
Caseload builds faster
Insurance-based clients are a much larger pool. Most people looking for therapy have coverage and want to use it. A new therapist on two or three panels can reach full caseload in 12 to 18 months. Private pay typically takes longer, especially outside major urban markets.
Some specialties match better
Trauma, eating disorders, and severe mood disorders are areas where clients often need insurance coverage for extended treatment. A therapist who specializes in these areas may find insurance necessary to serve their intended population.
EAP referrals are consistent
Employee Assistance Programs send steady referrals with no marketing required. The per-session rate is low ($65 to $85 typically), but the guaranteed volume can stabilize cash flow in slower periods.
Geographic realities
Private pay rates in rural or lower-income markets may not be financially sustainable. A therapist in a mid-size city where $120 is the market ceiling will find it harder to command $159 than one in a major metro.
Access to care
This is the ethical argument and it is real. Many people who genuinely need therapy cannot access it without insurance coverage. Whether individual therapists have a responsibility to solve a systemic access problem is debated. But some therapists stay on panels specifically for this reason and find it meaningful.
3The honest case for private pay
Beyond the income gap, private pay changes the clinical and administrative texture of your practice in ways that matter.
Full clinical autonomy
Insurance requires a billable diagnosis from session one. It limits session frequency and imposes treatment length restrictions through utilization review. Private pay removes those constraints. You can see a client biweekly indefinitely, or end at six sessions, entirely on clinical judgment.
No diagnosis on client record
Insurance claims create a permanent record of mental health diagnoses. This affects life insurance underwriting, some security clearances, and for some clients, the stigma of a formal diagnosis. Private pay clients who want to keep their treatment private can do so. Superbill clients can still access out-of-network reimbursement if they choose.
Simpler operations
No prior authorizations. No claims denials. No credentialing delays. No recoupment audits. A private pay practice is administratively far simpler, which translates to fewer hours on non-clinical work.
Same-day payment
Insurance pays 30 to 90 days after the service date. Private pay clients pay at the time of session. For cash flow and practice sustainability, same-day payment matters.
Rate flexibility
Insurance contracts lock you into a fee schedule. Private pay allows you to raise your rate as your experience, specialization, and reputation grow. A therapist who completes advanced training in EMDR or DBT can immediately reflect that in their fee. Panel rates do not move.
6The hybrid model
Most therapists do not choose a binary. The hybrid model (insurance panels for some clients, private pay for others) is how most established practices actually run, and it is a reasonable middle path.
The typical hybrid approach:
- 1Stay on one or two insurance panels you already have credentialed. Do not add new ones.
- 2Set a higher private pay rate for new non-insurance clients.
- 3When an insurance slot opens (termination, transfer), fill it with a private pay client if possible.
- 4Over 12 to 24 months, the ratio shifts naturally without a disruptive income gap.
- 5Check your panel contracts. Some require you to bill insurance for any client with that coverage, even if they would prefer to pay out of pocket.
The risk of the hybrid model is that it can become permanent inertia. Many therapists intend to transition and stay on panels for years because the short-term income from existing insurance clients feels too comfortable to disrupt. If transition is the goal, put a date on it.
7How to actually make private pay work
The therapists who successfully build private pay practices share a few consistent approaches:
Set your rate based on your costs, not the market average
Calculate your true minimum viable rate first: total monthly overhead divided by your target billable hours. Then check what the market supports. Your rate should be above your minimum viable rate and within the range for your experience and specialty. Starting too low and trying to raise later is harder than setting the right rate from the beginning.
Build a website that ranks
Most private pay clients find therapists through Google. A functional website optimized for local search terms will outperform any directory over time. This is a 12 to 18 month investment, not a 30-day fix. Start before you need it.
Develop a referral network outside directories
GPs, psychiatrists, pediatricians, school counselors, and HR professionals all make referrals to therapists they know. One solid relationship with a well-connected GP can send more private pay clients per year than a Psychology Today listing.
Specialize visibly
Private pay clients who have a choice of therapist tend to seek specialists. A therapist who is clearly the person for EMDR, postpartum, couples in distress, or executives can command a premium. Generalist private pay is harder to fill than specialist private pay.
Offer superbills for out-of-network reimbursement
Clients with PPO plans may receive 40 to 80% reimbursement for out-of-network therapy. Providing a superbill removes a financial objection without reducing your rate. Many clients do not know OON reimbursement is available until you tell them.
Keep a few sliding scale slots intentionally
A small number of reduced-fee slots addresses the access equity concern without undermining your practice economics. Two to three sliding scale clients in a 20-client caseload is meaningful clinically and keeps your practice viable financially.
8Decision framework: Which model is right for you
No framework survives contact with the full complexity of individual situations, but here is a useful starting point:
Consider staying on insurance panels if:
- You are in the first 2 years of private practice and need caseload volume
- You are in a rural or lower-income market where private pay rates are not meaningfully higher
- Your specialty (severe eating disorders, intensive trauma) requires extended treatment that insurance supports
- You have existing clients on panels you want to continue seeing
- Building a referral network or web presence feels inaccessible right now
Consider moving toward private pay if:
- You have 3+ years of practice and a starting referral network
- You are in an urban or suburban market where $150+ is common
- You are spending 3+ hours per week on prior auths and billing admin
- You want clinical autonomy over diagnosis and treatment length
- You have completed advanced training that justifies a specialty premium
- You are approaching burnout and the administrative load is a significant driver
One honest note: This is a decision where therapists in your own community will have the most useful input. The economics vary significantly by city, license type, and specialty. r/therapists has extensive threads on this question with real practitioner experience. That context is worth reading alongside the aggregate data.
Free: Net Income Comparison Worksheet
Calculate your actual effective hourly rate under each model. Accounts for admin time, billing costs, and caseload build time so you can compare apples to apples.
Free download. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
Should therapists accept insurance?
It depends on career stage, location, and specialty. Insurance panels make caseload-building easier early on. But Heard's 2025 data shows private pay therapists earn $159 per session versus $111 on insurance, a 43% gap. At 20 sessions per week that totals roughly $50,000 more per year in gross revenue. Most established therapists in urban markets find private pay more financially sustainable once they have a referral network.
How much more do private pay therapists make?
The average private pay rate is $159 per session versus $111 for insurance reimbursement, a difference of $48 per session or 43% more. At 20 sessions per week over 48 working weeks, that gap equals roughly $46,000 in additional gross revenue per year, before accounting for billing overhead costs that insurance adds.
Can I accept insurance and see private pay clients?
Yes. The hybrid model is common. Many therapists maintain one or two insurance panels while reserving slots for private pay clients at a higher rate. Check your panel contracts. Some require you to bill insurance for any client with that coverage, even if they would prefer to pay out of pocket.
How do I transition from insurance to private pay?
Stop accepting new insurance clients while honoring current commitments. Fill new slots with private pay clients. Raise your private pay rate to a sustainable level before fully leaving panels. Build referral sources outside directories: professional networks, specialty reputation, SEO. Most therapists complete the transition over 12 to 24 months.
What is a superbill in therapy?
A superbill is an itemized receipt that private pay therapists provide to clients so they can seek reimbursement from their insurance company directly. It includes your NPI number, diagnosis codes, procedure codes, session dates, and fees paid. Clients with PPO plans may receive 40 to 80% reimbursement for out-of-network therapy.
Is it ethical to only accept private pay?
This is genuinely debated in the profession. The argument against: private pay limits access. The argument for: insurance requires diagnoses that create permanent records, limits treatment length, and lower reimbursement rates can drive burnout. Many private pay therapists address equity concerns through sliding scale slots, pro bono work, or supervising therapists who do take insurance. There is no consensus position.
What is an out-of-network therapist?
An out-of-network therapist does not have a contract with a client's insurance company. Clients pay the therapist's full rate and may be partially reimbursed if they have out-of-network benefits. OON therapists can charge higher rates, avoid prior authorizations, and are not subject to insurer treatment limitations. Clients with PPO plans typically have OON coverage; HMO plans usually do not.
How do I find private pay therapy clients?
Private pay clients find therapists through Google search, AI recommendations, professional referrals, and word of mouth. The highest-ROI activities: local SEO for your practice website, specialty reputation in a specific area, and relationships with GPs, psychiatrists, and employee assistance contacts. Directories alone rarely sustain a full private pay caseload.
Spend your clinical hours on clients, not paperwork
Whichever model you choose, documentation time is the overhead line you can actually control. Reframe generates progress notes, personalized worksheets, and session materials in under 60 seconds. HIPAA-compliant by physics, not promises.
7-day free trial. No credit card required.